Cast

• Danny DeVito — Buddy Hall
• Matthew Broderick — Steve Finch
• Kristin Davis — Kelly Finch
• Kristin Chenoweth — Tia Hall
• Alia Shawkat — Madison Finch
• Dylan Blue — Carter Finch
• Kelly Aldridge — Ashley Hall
• Sabrina Aldridge — Emily Hall
• Fred Armisen — Gustave
• Jorge Garcia — Wallace
• Garry Chalk — Sheriff Dave
• David James Lewis — Ted
• Ken Kramer — Mr. Murray
• Jill Morrison — Gail
• Jill Krop — Reporter #2
• David Stuart — Oblivious Dad
• Quinn Lord — Santa Kid
• Eliza Norbury — Mary in the Manger
• Randi Lynne — Caroler #1
• Ty Olsson — Trucker
• Stephen Holmes — UPS Guy
• Andrew Hedge — City Employee
• Sean O'Bryan — Mayor Young
• Gillian Vigman — Gerta
• Ryan Devlin — Bob Murray
• Jackie Burroughs — Mrs. Ryor
• Nicola Peltz — Mackenzie
• Zak Santiago — Fireworks Guy
• Daniel Bacon — Ed
• Brenda Crichlow — News Reporter #1
• Agam Darshi — News Producer
• Fulvio Cecere — Town Passerby
• Dan Joffre — Caroler #2
• Cory Monteith — Madison's Date
• Suchin Pak — Herself