Cast

• Adrian Smith — Joey (2nd)
• Alice Dinnean — Sofie
• Allen Enlow — Samuel
• Andrew Sachs — Narrator
• Andy Stone — Additional Muppet Performer
• Ashley Carin — Sarah
• Ashley Jones — Neighborhood Kid #1
• Clare Sera — Josie the Mail Lady
• Cullen Douglas — Bernard the Crossing Guard
• Fran Brill — Nina
• Holly Bobo — Little Owl
• Jack Mountford — Joey (1st)
• James Spector — Ace
• Jamie Ryan — Neighborhood Kid #2
• Jeff Conover — Additional Muppet Performer
• Joey Mazzarino — Chelli
• Kevin Clash — Avery
• María Conchita Alonso — Troubles the Cat
• Matt Vogel — Additional Muppet Performer
• Pam Lewis — Little Chick
• Rickey Boyd — Argyle McSock
• Selena Nelson — Molly
• Tessa Ludwick — Kim