Cast

• Ashley Madekwe — Tituba
• Elise Eberle — Mercy Lewis
• Iddo Goldberg — Isaac
• Janet Montgomery — Mary Sibley
• Seth Gabel — Cotton Mather
• Shane West — John Alden
• Tamzin Merchant — Anne Hale
• Azure Parsons — Gloriana
• Emma Claire Wynn — Dorcas
• Jeremy Crutchley — Wendell Hathorne
• Joe Doyle — Baron Sebastian Marburg
• Lucy Lawless — Countess Palatine Ingrid von Marburg
• Michael Mulheren — George Sibley
• Oliver Bell — Boy
• Samuel Roukin — The Sentinel
• Stephen Lang — Increase Mather
• Stuart Townsend — Dr. Samuel Wainwright
• Xander Berkeley — Magistrate Hale